Critics Divided: Netflix’s Ripley Starring Andrew Scott

The Tale of Two Opinions

Praise and Criticism

Netflix’s TV drama Ripley, adapted from Patricia Highsmith’s thrilling novels, has garnered mixed reviews from critics. Andrew Scott’s portrayal of the fraudster Tom Ripley has sparked contrasting opinions among reviewers.

A Divergent Spectrum

The Guardian’s Acclaim

Lucy Mangan of The Guardian lauds Andrew Scott’s performance as “absolutely spellbinding”, awarding the show a stellar five stars. She describes the adaptation as “scintillating and noirish”, praising its fresh take on Highsmith’s renowned narrative.

Variety’s Disapproval

In contrast, Amaride Tinubu from Variety offers a dissenting view, labeling Scott’s portrayal as “utterly charmless”. Tinubu critiques the show for its lack of allure and likability, particularly highlighting the absence of homoerotic undertones present in previous adaptations.

The Story Unfolds

Setting and Plot

Set in 1960s New York, Ripley follows the exploits of Tom Ripley, dispatched to Italy on a mission to persuade a magnate’s son to return home. This narrative backdrop adds depth and intrigue to the character dynamics.

Echoes of Past Adaptations

Nostalgia and Comparison

Adam White from The Independent acknowledges the series as a decent adaptation, despite reservations about Scott’s suitability for the role. He notes the weight of past adaptations, suggesting that Ripley struggles to break free from the shadow of earlier iterations.

A Hitchcockian Masterpiece

The Times’ Perspective

Carole Midgley of The Times offers a contrasting viewpoint, hailing Ripley as “a Hitchcockian work of art”. She praises Scott’s performance as mesmerizing, portraying Ripley as a clever yet ruthless psychopath. Midgley’s review underscores the show’s allure and cinematic quality.

A Tale of Contrast

The Final Verdict

As critics continue to debate Ripley’s merits, it remains a subject of contention among audiences. While some commend its innovative approach and Scott’s captivating portrayal, others critique its departure from previous adaptations. Ultimately, Ripley’s legacy lies in its ability to evoke diverse responses from viewers.