A Stirring Debate

In the vibrant world of Carnatic music, recent events have sparked a flurry of discussions across social media platforms. At the center of this controversy is a strongly-worded response from The Music Academy directed towards the esteemed vocalist duo, Ranjani and Gayathri. Their decision to withdraw from participating in the Academy’s prestigious 2024 conference, citing objections to the selection of T.M. Krishna as this year’s Sangita Kalanidhi, has sent shockwaves through the community.

Ranjani and Gayathri’s Withdrawal

The vocal duo’s declaration to abstain from the upcoming annual conference has raised eyebrows and garnered significant attention. Their opposition to T.M. Krishna’s nomination for the Sangita Kalanidhi award has ignited a debate about the Academy’s selection process and the criteria for bestowing this esteemed honor.

The Music Academy’s Response

In a strongly-worded letter addressed to Ranjani and Gayathri, the President of The Music Academy, N. Murali, expressed deep disappointment and shock at the tone and content of their communication. He condemned what he described as “vituperative content” filled with “unwarranted and slanderous assertions,” emphasizing the Academy’s commitment to honoring excellence in Carnatic music.

The Academy’s Selection Process

Mr. Murali reaffirmed the Academy’s long-standing tradition of carefully deliberating the choice for Sangita Kalanidhi, solely based on musical excellence demonstrated over a significant and sustained career. He emphasized that T.M. Krishna’s selection was made by the Executive Committee without any external influence, solely based on his musical prowess.

Critique of Ranjani and Gayathri’s Actions

The President of The Music Academy criticized the vocal duo’s decision to publicize their grievances on social media, labeling it as discourteous and questioning the underlying intentions behind their letter. He urged them to reconsider their stance and engage in constructive dialogue rather than resorting to public criticism.

A Call for Dialogue

The rift between Ranjani, Gayathri, and The Music Academy highlights the complexities within the Carnatic music community. While disagreements are inevitable, fostering open communication and mutual respect is essential for preserving the integrity and richness of this cherished art form.